What is the Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliner?

What is the Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliner? Expert Opinion – 2022

Every makeup lover has a special place for eyeliner in their heart. It is almost everyone’s favorite type of makeup, without which the look is incomplete. But if you have sensitive skin, wear contact lenses, or are prone to allergies, chances are that wearing eyeliner can irritate your eyes and cause damage. Therefore, it is important to use makeup products with caution, especially around the eyes as they are the most sensitive parts of the face. Using hypoallergenic eyeliners is a great solution to this problem. These products minimize the risk of irritation, allergies, or any other harm and keep your eyes away from harm’s way while making you look beautiful.

Before heading over to a shop to buy a hypoallergenic eyeliner, it is important to know what the word even means. Hypoallergenic eye products are ophthalmologist-tested and have fewer allergic reactions than normal products. They have gentle, neutral, and natural ingredients and are safe to use on the eyes or any other part of the face. They are free from all toxic chemicals that could potentially cause irritation or an allergic reaction. However, you must always check the ingredient list for any hypoallergenic product that you buy because no matter how good they are for sensitive skin, you can always be allergic to something even if it is not a harmful chemical.

Numerous brands have released hypoallergenic eyeliners that are of high quality and long-lasting. To make it easier for you to choose from reliable brands, we have compiled a list of different hypoallergenic eyeliners that guarantee amazing results. Other than being completely safe to use, they are top-notch products that last throughout the day and complete your entire look.

1. Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil:

Neutrogena Nourishing

Neutrogena Nourishing

This eyeliner from Neutrogena has always been one of the most famous hypoallergenic eye products on the market. True to its name, the Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil consists of olive oil, shea butter, and light diffusers, all of which boost the health of your eye while keeping it protected.

This incredible hypoallergenic product comes with a built-in sharpener and a smudger. These additions to the amazing eyeliner formula ensure that you can apply the perfect liner on the go. It will enhance your makeup look and brighten your eyes while keeping them away from any harm. You can also check out the best makeup kits

2. Almay Eyeliner with built-in sharpener:

Almay Eyeliner

Almay Eyeliner

The Almay Eyeliner is specially made for those with sensitive eyes. It lasts for up to sixteen hours, so even on a hot and humid day, there will be no need for you to retouch your liner. The built-in sharpener in the Almay liner ensures that you have extra precision while applying it, so that you can get really close to your lash line and get the perfect wing.

The main benefit of this hypoallergenic eyeliner is that it includes Vitamin E which nourishes and protects your sensitive eyelids. Not only does it prevent any irritation or allergic reactions, but it also ensures that your eye remains healthy after a full day of makeup. The formula is smudge-proof and applies smoothly on the lid, ensuring that you have a professional-level eyeliner wherever you go.

3. Physicians Formula Eye Booster: 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner:

Physicians Formula

Physicians Formula

The Lash Boosting Eyeliner is the perfect lab-made chemical formula. Though it lacks the usual natural ingredients in most hypoallergenic eyeliners, it has done a remarkable job in keeping your sensitive eyes safe and nourished. It offers an easy application, thanks to its smooth formula and fine tip which allows you to draw precise lines on your lid.

Though it is not waterproof and fades away quicker than most liners, it has tremendous benefits which boost the visibility and health of your lashes, hence the name. It nourishes, strengthens, and hydrates your lashes with each application without causing any irritation or damage.

4. L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner:

L’Oreal Paris

L’Oreal Paris

The L’Oreal Paris Infallible eyeliner is the perfect mix of natural and non-natural ingredients which give maximized results. It is known famously as the “Never Fail” eyeliner – for all the right reasons. It has a smooth, glide-like, and easy application, allowing you to achieve the exact result that you want. Also, check out the best eye makeup for sensitive eyes.

It is the perfect eye product for amateurs and professionals, alike. It is a luxurious skin-friendly product that lasts for at least 16 hours on your lids. It is smudge-proof and made from organic products that boost the health of your eyelids and do not cause any irritation.

5. Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen:

Pixi Endless

Pixi Endless

This hypoallergenic product comes in various shades of brown and blue, which is just one of the incredible things about it. This gel liner is free from all parabens, mineral oils, and preservatives that are likely to be harmful to the eye. Instead, it includes vitamin E which is a healthy ingredient for the eyelid.

It is a long-lasting formula that offers easy, smooth, and foolproof application. It is completely smudge-proof and is without a doubt, one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners out there.

6. KROMA Eye Liner:


KROMA Eye Liner

Though it is a bit pricey as compared to other products, the KROMA eyeliner is one of the topmost hypoallergenic eyeliners. It is very easy to apply and lasts on your face for a long time, so the cost is surely worth it. You can choose from a wide range of eleven colors in this collection, depending on your style and eye color.

The formula goes on effortlessly on the skin, avoiding any rashes or irritation on the eyelids. Its nourishing ingredients give your eyelids that extra health boost and prevent allergic reactions or burning sensations. These highly pigmented eyeliners are perfect for a night out or any special event.

How to Check if you are allergic to Eyeliner?

Even if you buy the most expensive hypoallergenic eyeliner, you can still be allergic to it if you are allergic to any ingredients in it. Therefore, it is important to know which hypoallergenic eyeliner works best for you. Luckily, it is very easy to tell if you are having an allergic reaction due to an eyeliner since you will experience any one of the following symptoms. But it is still highly suggested that you check the ingredients list in every product, for anything that you might be allergic to, in order to avoid any unfortunate incident from happening.


  1. Redness: If the whites of your eyes suddenly turn red after you apply an eye liner, chances are that you are allergic to it, or you have some type of infection. This is a big hint for you to remove the eyeliner to avoid the situation from worsening.
  2. Watery Eyes: though it is completely normal for our eyes to water from time to time, it is a great tell for an allergic reaction. If your eyes start watering profusely, it is likely that you are allergic to the eyeliner that you just put on.
  3. Swelling: If your eyelids or the skin around your eye swell up, you must remove all of your eye makeup immediately. This is one of the biggest signs of an allergic reaction due to a product.
  4. Burning Sensations: makeup is not meant to hurt, so if your eyes start burning or stinging after you apply it, you might be allergic to it.
  5. Itching or Irritation: this is the biggest sign of an allergic reaction to an ingredient in your makeup product. Eyeliner is supposed to go on smoothly without causing any irritation, so if it does happen, it is a sign that you need to change the brand you are using.

Remember that makeup is only supposed to make you look and feel beautiful, not cause you any sort of discomfort. Try out these reliable hypoallergenic eyeliners to keep your sensitive eyelids safe from any allergic reactions. But if you do end up getting one, make sure to first remove your makeup and wash your face properly. If the allergy gets worse, it is best to consult your doctor before making rash decisions on your own.

Leave a Comment